Animation or Live Action? March 4, 2009Posted by smike97k in cyborgs.
Tags: animation, anime, Fisher Center Lecture Series, Grave of the Fireflies, Live action
add a comment
During the discussion after the screening of “Grave of the Fireflies,” the question of whether the film would have been as heart wrenching, or more so, if it had been made in life action. The film actually was transferred to live action; however most of us had not seen that version. An argument was made that it would most likely be more relatable and intense if it had been live action, with actual human characters, because it would be easier to relate to them as other human beings in terms of their physical bodies. I had a different opinion of this question. I thought that the animation was more intense than it would have been in live action. Though I might change my mind if I were to see the live action version, I felt that the fact that it was animated, allowed for the character’s facial expression and movements to be extremely exaggerated, exaggerating the intensity of their feelings, fears, and appearances. The intensity of feeling and fear struck me especially in the character of the young girl. There was something about her intense and ever changing facial expressions that really left no room for interpretation; if she was upset, you knew it for sure. I think this is because of the detail in the drawing aspect of animation creation. Animating pays special attention to detail of each element within the individual drawing. Because it is not “live” or “real life” an animator needs to exaggerate the characteristics of the subject so that they are sure to get across. I think that that is what made this piece so powerful. The emotion felt, especially from the young girl, was inescapable.
Someone brought up in class the point that it made it easier to feel more for these characters because they weren’t actual humans playing them. It allowed us to remove our selves far enough away from reality that we actually could end up feeling more. I thought this was an interesting idea. Often times, in live action, what is being portrayed is too frightening to take in because you are seeing “real live” people take place in it, and so one may shut off connection to the characters out of fear. On the other hand, the animation takes us away from our fears of this happening to us because we are “live” so that we can enter more into the story.
Patching up the patchwork February 20, 2009Posted by andiroo in cyborgs.
Tags: animation, literature, monster, patchwork girl, Shelley Jackson
I’ll be quite honest – trying to read Patchwork Girl on my own was… difficult. Now I am not sure if it was my computer or if it was my inability to follow the .pdf guidelines, but surely something was working against me. I would click here, and something would pop-up there – a jumbled mess, in my opinion, with no direction or any conceivable end results. However, at the lecture I was enlightened by the truth of her work, and I was astonished at how well it was written – how well it made me connect, and how it made me feel the words she wrote, more than just listening to them.
Her whole approach to writing, reading, and everything in between baffled me at first, but I think that’s just because she hit the nail on the head. I sensed right off the bat that she knew what she was talking about, instead of talking about something she knew – her dedication to literature, and to animation is ever-clear and her ideas were equally as amazing. She really gave me an insight into the fabrication that writing truly is – a piece by piece construction of our own entity – be it a monster, or be it something else, and this I really enjoyed.
Too bad I still can’t figure out how to read it on my computer 😦